Using AI Tools for Blended Learning: Educator Dilemmas and Solutions

AI’s Role in the Flipped and Blended Classroom

Image created by Samara Marin Using Adobe Firefly 2024

ai’s Evolution

Many find it hard to believe that artificial intelligence (AI) existed before the 21st century. The first historical example of Generative AI (GAI) was an early version of a chatbot today, created in the 1960s by Joseph Weizenbaum. Once a computer program is created, it will naturally be studied and undergo upgrades, branching out into different program versions. Thanks to Eliza, the original 1960s chatbot, we got Siri in the 2010s, followed by ChatGPT in the 2020s. Artificial intelligence has slowly surrounded everyday life through phones, autocompletion in search engines, and even grammar tools in our word processors. However, the ease of access to generative AI and how easily students can use GAI to create completed assignments has become a discussion topic involving the educational environment.

Image created by Samara Marin Using Microsoft Copilot 2024

Educators’ Dilema

Due to the recent boom in GAI, educators are facing a new dilemma: What is considered the ethical use of AI? At what point is it the educators’ duty to teach the ethics of AI? Recently, while at an externship at Lamar University (LU) in Beaumont, TX, many of the nursing school faculty stated they noticed students are using AI. However, Dr. Dockens stated that with AI’s use in the educational environment being so new due to the introduction of GPTs, many policies can only be suggestions to faculty. So, she showed three proposed policies for faculty to use at LU, ranging from no AI use under any circumstances to AI use being acceptable when the faculty allows it. The dilemma educators face is that AI is here, it is evolving, and discussions are being had on how AI should be used in the classroom. So, how can AI be used ethically?

Image created by Samara Marin Using Microsoft Copilot 2024

AI Tools for the Classroom

Image created by Samara Marin Using Microsoft Copilot 2024

For educators to feel more comfortable having conversations about AI in the classroom, educators can start by using tools that help the educator in the planning phase. For educators, “AI can be used for task automation, administrative work, analyzing learning patterns, grading homework, responding to general queries, and various other educational processes” (2023). Two beginner-friendly tools for educators are Khanmigo and Magicschool.AI. For educators who feel comfortable with AIs, Microsoft Copilot is being streamlined into all Microsoft apps. Finally, Grammarly is the first AI I use in the classroom, and I ensure all students leave my class with an account. Once the educator feels comfortable with the tools, these tools can be used to help create a blended classroom environment.

Khanmigo

Khanmigo is Sal Khan’s addition to the AI world specifically for education. It has 24 free action-specific tools for educators, which can then be categorized depending on what the educator tries to do. Whether differentiating, creating, or even learning something new, Sal Khan understood that educators might be new to the AI world. Khanmigo makes it easy for educators to integrate AI into their classrooms as the tools can also translate into student use as activities. Khanmigo is also an AI tutor for students who assist with problem-solving instead of simply giving students answers.

Image depicts a screen capture of Khanmigo's teacher dashboard.
Marin, S. 2024 Screen Capture of Khanmigo

Magicschool.AI

Magicschool.AI is similar to Khanmigo because it integrates action-specific AIs into the platform for students and educators. The key difference is that Magicschool.AI has 60+ compared to Khanmigo’s 24; however, this is due to Magicschool.AI being a paid platform. The extra generators are worth it for educators who are more comfortable with the AI world.

Marin, S. 2024 Screen Capture of Magicschool.AI

Microsoft Copilot

Microsoft Copilot is a chatbot that can help educators who simply need to get their ideas flowing. If an educator has an idea but no one to speak to, they can begin by asking Copilot for a simple prompt. For example, “I would like to create a project for my 10th-grade English class using Kate Chopin’s The Story of an Hour; how can I make it historical?” Copilot will give responses along with clickable links to where it found its information, shown below by the numbers 3 and 1.

Marin, S. 2024 Screen Capture of Microsoft Copilot

Grammarly

Grammarly is a grammar-based AI that I have used in my classroom for years. It is more thorough and explains why it suggests the change, so I use it instead of simply using the AIs built into students’ word processors. This creates an environment in which students are still responsible for reading the reasoning behind the suggestion and making the final decision about accepting or rejecting the change. Grammarly has been keeping up with the evolution of AI by integrating an education platform into its services that works for educational institutions.

Marin, S. 2024 Screen Capture of Grammarly

AI-Based Cheating VS. the Flipped Classroom

Image created by Samara Marin Using Microsoft Copilot 2024

One of educators’ main concerns for allowing AI in their classrooms is students’ academic dishonesty. Educators who want to venture into AI integration for their classrooms could use the flipped classroom model to help combat cheating. Regarding the flipped classroom model, most, if not all, projects/assignments are done in the classroom while lectures are watched at home, replacing homework. If students are completing assignments that require them to show knowledge acquisition in class, this will defer any cheating attempts as the assignments are being completed with the educator present. This will also allow for discussions about AI use ethics during instructional time. If AI is presented as a tool for learning, they will use it that way. If it’s seen as a tool for cheating, they will use it for cheating.

There’s No Hiding From AI

Discussions about what is ethical when using AI are happening with or without educators involved. Students will use AI, whether for cheating or learning, depending on how they are taught. Additionally, educators avoid AI integration into their classrooms because they feel underprepared. However, for educators to feel more comfortable using AI, they first must learn how to use it. That being said, educators have other priorities throughout the year that they must complete. The unease about using AI in the classroom can be alleviated by professional development offered by administrators as a part of the mandatory workshop days.

Image created by Samara Marin Using Microsoft Copilot 2024

How Do Educators Feel About AI?

Image created by Samara Marin Using Adobe Firefly 2024

I interviewed two of my classmates to discover how some of my classmates felt about the same topic. Both are currently educators in different grade levels and educational settings. Amongst the three of us, we cover elementary to high school, public, charter, and private schools. Maria teaches 1st through 8th grade Spanish at a private school. Amburh teaches all subjects for her 2nd-grade class in a public school, while I teach English in a charter high school.

References

Image created by Samara Marin using Adobe Firefly 2024

Adam Zewe   |   MIT News. (n.d.). Explained: Generative AI. MIT News | Massachusetts

Institute of Technology. https://news.mit.edu/2023/explained-generative-ai-1109 

AI in education: How Artificial Intelligence is Impacting the Classroom. Computeam.

(n.d.).https://www.computeam.co.uk/videos-and-blog/article/ai-in-education-how-artificial-intelligence-is-impacting-the-classroom 

Artificial Intelligence. Lamar.edu. (n.d.).

https://www.lamar.edu/lu-online/faculty-services/center-for-teaching-and-learning-enhancement/ai/index.html

Demir, B. (2023, August 17). How can AI tools be utilized to increase Classroom

Engagement? Twin Science. https://www.twinscience.com/en/teacher-tips/how-to-utilise-ai-tools-to-increase-classroom-engagement/

DeVille, K. (2024, May 10). How to Use AI for Teachers: Enhancing Classroom Learning.

STEM Education Guide. https://stemeducationguide.com/ai-for-teachers/

Embracing Artificial Intelligence in the Classroom. Harvard Graduate School of

Education.(n.d.).https://www.gse.harvard.edu/ideas/usable-knowledge/23/07/embracing-artificial-intelligence-classroom

Ethical AI for teaching and learning: Center for teaching innovation. Ethical AI for

Teaching and Learning | Center for Teaching Innovation. (n.d.).

https://teaching.cornell.edu/generative-artificial-intelligence/ethical-ai-teaching-a

d-learning

Free, AI-powered Teacher Assistant by Khan Academy. Khanmigo. (n.d.).

https://www.khanmigo.ai/teachers

Foote, K. D. (2024, March 5). A Brief History of Generative AI. DATAVERSITY.

Forbes Magazine. (2024, March 6). Artificial Intelligence in Education: Teachers’ Opinions

on AI in the Classroom. Forbes.

https://www.forbes.com/advisor/education/it-and-tech/artificial-intelligence-in-school/

Getting Started with Ai-Enhanced Teaching: A Practical Guide for Instructors. MIT Sloan

Teaching & Learning Technologies. (2024, May 6).

https://mitsloanedtech.mit.edu/ai/teach/getting-started/

Grammarly for Education. Grammarly. (n.d.). https://www.grammarly.com/edu

Kim, N. J., & Kim, M. K. (2022, February 22). Teacher’s Perceptions of Using an Artificial

Intelligence-Based Educational Tool for Scientific Writing. Frontiers.

https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/education/articles/10.3389/feduc.2022.755914/full

Parker, Dr. J. (2024, January 29). Educator Edtech Review: Magic school ai.

TechLearningMagazine.

https://www.techlearning.com/news/educator-edtech-review-magic-school-ai

Professional Writing Starts in the Classroom: Building Career Readiness Through

Communication. Grammarly. (2022, September 13).

https://www.grammarly.com/blog/building-career-readiness/

Sammour, G. (2023, October 19). A Practical Agenda for Using AI in the Classroom.

AACSB.

https://www.aacsb.edu/insights/articles/2023/05/a-practical-agenda-for-using-ai-in

the-classroom

Team, M. E. (2024, June 3). Meet your AI Assistant for Education: Microsoft Copilot.

Microsoft Education Blog.

https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/education/blog/2024/01/meet-your-ai-assistant-f

r-education-microsoft-copilot/

Walter, Y. (2024, February 26). Embracing the Future of Artificial Intelligence in the

Classroom: The Relevance of AI Literacy, Prompt Engineering, and Critical

Thinking in Modern Education – International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education. SpringerOpen. https://educationaltechnologyjournal.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s41239-024-00448-3

YouTube. (2023, May 1). How AI Could Save (Not Destroy) Education | Sal Khan | Ted.

YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hJP5GqnTrNo&t=481s 

RAW is a WordPress blog theme design inspired by the Brutalist concepts from the homonymous Architectural movement.

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive our very latest news.

Go back

Your message has been sent

Warning
Warning
Warning.

5 responses to “Using AI Tools for Blended Learning: Educator Dilemmas and Solutions”

  1. […] week or month, we revert to what we know. (If you are interested in the full interview, it is at the bottom of this page). The influencer model can create a simple culture of ensuring that educators in an organization […]

    Like

  2. […] the publication, we moved on to our media project. I wanted to show the AI tools I mentioned in my Publication’s final draft, so I needed to record a video, not a podcast. However, the problem of having a monotone intonation […]

    Like

  3. […] of the AI platforms I recommend to first-time AI users in the educational field are in blog post Using AI Tools For Blended Learning. These tools are either specific to educators or simple to use for first time users, which are […]

    Like

  4. […] to continue on the same path they are already following. To address these challenges, I compiled a list of AI tools that can assist educators in their planning processes, along with the benefits of using AI for this […]

    Like

Leave a reply to 4DX Model: Implementing WIGs for Effective Organizational Change – Marin's Eportfolio Cancel reply